Best Comic Book Superhero Movie of Summer '08?

[WingedAvenger]

Alright, let's have it out. Vote for the best comic book superhero movie of this past summer.

[WingedAvenger]

3 days later:

11 views.
3 votes.
No replies.

...the hell? :yoy:

[ThunderMace]

The Dark Knight, but not by much, due to RDJ's epic performence in Iron Man

[Sebastian Kain]

After rewatching Iron Man recently, I liked both of them equally.

I still need to watch the Hulk. :(

[Bitter Babe]

Hmm this is a hard choice. Loved both the Dark Knight and Iron Man, same as SK I haven't seen the Hulk yet.

[Antares]

Iron Man, hands down.

[iggy880]

I actually have to say Iron Man. I loved Dark Knight, I really did but Iron Man I felt was the best Comic Book Superhero Movie. It stayed truer, it was fun and action packed but still had good characters.

Dark Knight was a brilliant movie, brilliant acting and great story but it wasn't the best comic book movie as it strayed a bit.

And last, Hulk fell short, I mean it wasn't bad, still fun and they actually characterized Banner and Hulk better then usual but it just didn't shine.

[Dr Jack Wolfe]

I had more fun at Iron Man. So it wins for me. Dark Knight may have been better for emo type :P

[Graphite]

Ironman, hands down.
However "Rise of the Joker" made a great Batman movie.
:chuckle:

[suburbanhell]

Iron Man was the funnest movie, TDK was the best movie.

[Stec]

I can't vote on this one. I've only seen The Dark Knight so far. :cry:

[First Player]

Iron Man seemed more "superhero-ish" to me, if that makes any sense. The Dark Knight was incredibly well done as well though. Iron Man was just more fun.

Of course this could just be my preference of Marvel over DC speaking.

[Solario]

Dark Knight was the better of the two movies, but both were awesome. And Hulk wasn't bad.


Iron Man, while very, very good, and really the pitch perfect superhero movie, didn't really tread any new ground, whereas Dark Knight subverted the entire superhero genre and completely changed the playing ground for what you can do with a superhero movie.

[Joe Schmoe]

I'm surprised Iron Man is winning! Hell, it WAS a fun movie, but the action/lines in Dark Knight was too sweet. They don't even compare in my mind.

[Plasma Wisp]

I voted for Hulk, simply because it was such a great improvement to the first one in 2000.

Iron Man was going to rock. Dark Knight was going to be epic. Hulk was unexpectedly good.

[Stec]

After seeing Iron Man (Still have to see Hulk) I have to say that Iron Man was better.

Iron Man was not only good, but it made me laugh. Dark Knight was awesome, and I liked both equally, but Iron Man was more fun to watch than Dark Knight.